Authenticity as authenticating—the case of New Orleans jazz revivalism: An approach from grounded theory and social world analysis

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

    Abstract

    This article considers the emergence and development of New Orleans jazz revivalism in terms of a conceptual framework developed around the core category of ‘authenticating’. It developsa grounded theory of authenticating conceptualized as a ‘basic social process’ and constructs a phased trajectory of authenticating that incorporates the major sub-processes identified as‘sourcing’, ‘selecting’, ‘adopting’, ‘adapting’ and ‘progressing’ authenticity. The article sets these sub-processes within competing social worlds of jazz authenticity and purism, as they and their accompanying ideologies have variously emerged and segmented.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)24-52
    JournalPopular Music History
    Volume7
    Issue number1
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Feb 2012

    Bibliographical note

    © Equinox Publishing Ltd 2013
    Reference text: Adorno, Theodor W. 1936. ‘On Jazz’. In Theodor W. Adorno, Essays on Music, 470–95.
    Berkeley: University of California Press, 2002.
    Anon. c. 1960. ‘Sleeve Notes’. Bunk Johnson and his New Orleans Band. Brunswick, EP. OE
    9257.
    Bell, Graeme. 1988. Graeme Bell—Australian Jazzman: His Autobiography, with discography
    by Jack Mitchell. Frenchs Forest, NSW: Child and Associates.
    Bethell, Tom. 1977. George Lewis: A Jazzman from New Orleans. Berkeley: University of California
    Press.
    —2001. ‘Booklet Notes’. Kid Howard at San Jacinto Hall, GHB, BCD-23.
    —2002. ‘Booklet Notes’. George Lewis at San Jacinto Hall, GHB, BCD-34.
    Bird, Roger. 1977. ‘Sleeve Notes’. Andrew Hall’s Band, Rampart Records, LP. RS 104.
    Bissonnette, Big Bill. 1992. The Jazz Crusade: The Inside Story of the Great New Orleans Jazz
    Revival of the 1960s. Bridgeport, CN: Special Request Books.
    Blesh, Rudi. 1958 [1946]. Shining Trumpets: A History of Jazz, 4th enlarged ed. London:
    Cassell.
    Blumer, Herbert. 1954. ‘What is Wrong with Social Theory?’ American Sociological Review 18:
    3–10. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2088165
    Brackett, David. 2000. Interpreting Popular Music. Berkeley: University of California Press.
    http://dx.doi.org/10.1525/california/9780520225411.001.0001
    Brinkman, Shannon, and Eve Abrams. 2011. Preservation Hall. Photographs by Shannon
    Brinkman, Interviews with Preservation Hall Members by Eve Abrams. Baton Rouge:
    Louisiana State University Press.
    Broun, Heywood Hale. 1991. ‘From an Interview Done in 1991’. Booklet notes, ‘Kid Rena
    1940: Prelude to the Revival, Vol. II’. American Music. AMCD-41, 5–7.
    Brunn, H. O. 1961. The Story of the Original Dixieland Jazz Band. London: Sidgwick and
    Jackson.
    Bryce, Owen. 2001. The George Webb Dixielanders: My Part: The First Ten Years of the British
    Jazz Revival, 2nd ed. Blisworth: Owen Bryce.
    Buchanan, John. 1996. Emperor Norton’s Hunch: The Story of Lu Watters’ Yerba Buena Jazz
    Band. Sausolita, CA: Hambleton.
    Burns, Mike, ed. 2007. Walking with Legends: Barry Martyn’s New Orleans Jazz Odyssey. Baton
    Rouge: Louisiana State University Press.
    Carter, William. 1991. Preservation Hall: Music from the Heart. New York: W. W. Norton.
    Charters, Samuel B. 1963. Jazz: New Orleans 1885–1963: An Index to the Negro Musicians of
    New Orleans. New York: Oak Publications.
    —2008. A Trumpet Around the Corner: The Story of New Orleans Jazz. Jackson: University of
    Mississippi Press.
    Chilton, John. 2004. ‘Pawson, Dan’. In John Chilton, Who’s Who of British Jazz, 2nd ed.,
    274–75. London: Continuum.
    Cohen, Stanley. 1973. Folk Devils and Moral Panics. London: MacGibbon and Kee.
    Colyer, Ken. 1952a. ‘Letter to Bill Colyer, 3 December 1952’. In Ken Colyer, ‘Letters from New
    Orleans’. Ken Colyer Website. Available at http://www.kencolyer.org/
    —1952b. ‘Letter to Bill Colyer, 7 December 1952’. In Ken Colyer, ‘Letters from New Orleans’.
    Ken Colyer Website. Available at http://www.kencolyer.org/
    —c. 1960. New Orleans and Back. Produced for Ken Colyer by Arthur Brooks and Ken Pratt.
    Delph, Yorks.
    —2009. When Dreams are in Dust: The Path of a Jazzman, newly restored version. London:
    Ken Colyer Trust.
    Curran, Dale. 1947. ‘Three Brass, Four Rhythm’. In Jazzways, ed. George S. Rosenthal and
    Frank Zachary in collaboration with Frederic Ramsey, Jr. and Rudi Blesh, 103–109.
    London: Musicians Press.
    Davies, Russell. 1986. ‘Sleeve Notes’. ‘Humphrey Lyttelton and Russell Davies Present…
    Gonna Call My Children Home: The World of Buddy Bolden’. Caligraph, LP. CLGLP
    013.
    Delaunay, Charles. 1936. Hot Discographie. Paris: Jazz Hot.
    DeVore, Charlie. 1998. ‘New Orleans Memories, Part 1: Interviews with Charlie DeVore’,
    ed. William J. Schafer. Mississippi Rag 26.2 (December): 1, 2, 4–6.
    Eatherton, Fred and Richard Ekins. 2012. Dan Pawson – A Discography: Dan Pawson on Vinyl,
    Tape, CD and DVD (1960–2002), http://www.lacroixrecords.com/DP.html.
    Ekins, Richard. 2008a. ‘Back on Track: The Case of the Louis James Orchestra’ [Letter to the
    Editor]. New Orleans Music 14.4: 25.
    —2008b. ‘Dan Pawson: A Tribute’. 504/La Croix CD93, booklet notes, 1–16.
    —2008c. ‘Pitch Monitoring, Pitch Correction and the Case of the Louis James Orchestra,
    1967’. New Orleans Music 14.3: 6–14.
    —2009a. ‘Bob Wallis on Authenticity and the New Orleans Jazz Revival in Britain’. Just Jazz
    138 (October): 22–27.
    —2009b. ‘Dan Pawson: Living the Legend’, 504/La Croix, CD96, booklet notes, 1–16.
    —2010. ‘Traditional Jazz and the Mainstreaming of Authenticity: The Case of British Traddy
    Pop (1959–1963)—a Grounded Theory Approach’. Popular Music History 5.2: 125–50.
    —2011. ‘The Rediscovery and Resurrection of Bunk Johnson—a Grounded Theory Approach:
    A Case Study in Jazz Historiography’. The Grounded Theory Review 10.3: 27–54.
    Foreman, Ronald C., Jr. 1968. ‘Jazz and Race Records, 1920–1932: Their Origins and their
    Significance for the Record Industry and Society’. Unpublished PhD thesis. University
    of Illinois.
    Frith, Simon. 1988. ‘Playing with Real Feeling—Jazz and Suburbia’. In Simon Frith, Music for
    Pleasure, 45–63. Cambridge: Polity Press.
    Fry, Alderson, Max Caplan and William C. Love. 1942. Who’s Who in Jazz Collecting. Nashville:
    Hemphill Press.
    Gendron, Bernard. 1995. ‘“Mouldy Figs” and Modernists: Jazz at War (1942–1946)’. In Jazz
    Amongst the Discourses, ed. Krin Gabbard, 31–56. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
    Gennari, John. 2006. Blowin’ Hot and Cool: Jazz and its Critics. Chicago: University of Chicago
    Press.
    Glaser, Barney G. 1978. Theoretical Sensitivity: Advances in the Methodology of Grounded Theory.
    Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press.
    —1992. Basics of Grounded Theory Research. Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press.
    —1996. ‘Introduction’. In Gerund Grounded Theory: The Basic Social Process Dissertation, ed.
    Barney G. Glaser, ix–xvii. Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press.
    —2006. Flyer, Doing Formal Grounded Theory: A Proposal. Mill Valley, California: Sociology
    Press. Available at http://www.sociologypress.com/books/classic_series/Doing-
    FormalGroundedTheory.htm
    Glaser, Barney G., and Anselm L. Strauss. 1967. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for
    Qualitative Research. Chicago: Aldine.
    Goodey, Brian R. 1968. New Orleans to London: Twenty Years of the New Orleans Jazz
    Revival in Britain’. Journal of Popular Culture 2.2: 173–94. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/
    j.0022-3840.1968.0202_173.x
    Greenwood, Robert. 2009. ‘Dan Pawson (1936–2002): Obituary’, cited in Richard Ekins,
    ‘Booklet Notes’ , Dan Pawson: Living the Legend, 1971-1998, 504/La Croix, CD96,
    p. 13.
    Gronbeck, Bruce E. 2001. ‘The Idea of Structure and Communication in David Maines’
    Work’. In Studies in Symbolic Interaction, Volume 24, ed. Norman K. Denzin, 7–14.
    Bingley: Emerald Group.
    Gushee, Lawrence. 2002. ‘New Orleans Jazz’. In New Grove Dictionary of Jazz, Volume Two,
    2nd ed., ed. Barry Kernfeld, 887–88. New York: Grove.
    Hadlock, Richard. 2000. ‘The New Orleans Revival’. In The Oxford Companion to Jazz, ed. Bill
    Kirchner, 305–15. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
    Hansen, Chadwick. 1960. ‘Social Influences on Jazz Style: Chicago, 1920–30’. American
    Quarterly 12.4: 493–507. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2710331
    Hardie, Daniel. 2007. The Birth of Jazz: Reviving the Music of the Bolden Era. New York:
    iUniverse.
    Hazeldine, Mike (compiled and ed.). 1993. Bill Russell’s American Music. New Orleans: Jazzology Press.
    Hersch, Charles. 2008. ‘Reconstructing the Jazz Tradition’. Jazz Research Journal 2.1: 7–28.
    Jacobsen, Thomas W. 2011. Traditional New Orleans Jazz: Conversations with the Men who
    Make the Music. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press.
    Johnson, Bunk. 1947. ‘Last Testament of Great Jazzman’. Columbia, LP. GL 520.
    Katz, Mark. 2010. Capturing Sound: How Technology has Changed Music. Berkeley: University
    of California Press.
    Ken Colyer Trust. 1989–2010. Ken Colyer Trust Newsletter. London: Ken Colyer Trust.
    Korner, Alexis.1962. ‘Sleeve Notes’. ‘Too Busy’, Ken Colyer’s Jazzmen. Columbia, EP. SEG 8180.
    LaRocca, Nick. 1960. ‘Last Will and Testament—The Story of Jazz as Told by Nick & Discussion
    on Bix Beiderbecke’. A Kazoo Lips Production. CD-2008.
    Lee, Raymond. 2001. Dan Pawson Discography. Zwolle, Netherlands: Gerard Bielderman.
    Leonard, Marion, and Robert Strachan. 2003. ‘Authenticity’. In Continuum Encyclopedia of
    Popular Music of the World, Volume 1: Media, Industry and Society, ed. John Shepherd,
    David Horn, Dave Laing, Paul Oliver and Peter Wicke, 164–66. London: Continuum.
    Levine, Lawrence W. 1988. Highbrow/Lowbrow: The Emergence of Cultural Hierarchy in America:
    Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
    —1989. ‘Jazz and American Culture’. Journal of American Folklore 102: 6–22. http://dx.doi.
    org/10.2307/540078
    Lewis, George. 1943a. ‘George Lewis and his New Orleans Stompers, Vol. 1—Echoes of New
    Orleans’. Blue Note LP 7010.
    —1943b. ‘George Lewis and his New Orleans Stompers, Vol. 2—Echoes of New Orleans’.
    Blue Note LP 7013.
    Maines, David. 1982. ‘In Search of Mesostructures: Studies in the Negotiated Order’. Urban
    Life 11: 267–79.
    Marquis, Don. 2005. In Search of Buddy Bolden, rev. ed. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisian University
    Press.
    Martyn, Barry. 1972. ‘Barry Martyn at Large’. Footnote 3.3 (February): 16–23.
    —1998. New Orleans Jazz: The End of the Beginning. New Orleans: Jazzology Press.
    McKay, George. 2005. Circular Breathing: The Cultural Politics of Jazz in Britain. Durham, NC:
    Duke University Press.
    Melly, George. 1984. ‘Ken Colyer and the First Traditional Jazz Band’. Available at http://www.
    youtube.com/watch?v=PYxok6qb6M4, from ‘Whatever Happened to Bill Brunskill?’,
    Thames TV.
    Authenticity as authenticating 51
    © Equinox Publishing Ltd 2013.
    Merriam, Alan P., and Fradley H. Garner. 1998. ‘Jazz—the Word’. In The Jazz Cadence of American
    Culture, ed. Robert G. O’Meally, 7–31. New York: Columbia University Press.
    Mills, Grayson. 1960. ‘New Orleans Music: Root, Bone and Marrow, Flower: A Report on
    Icon Records’ Objectives and Realities’. Jazz Report 1.4 (December): 13.
    Monaco, Jeanette. 2010. ‘Memory Work, Autoethnography and the Construction of a Fan-
    Ethnography’. Participations: Journal of Audience and Reception Studies 7.1: 105–42.
    Moore, Allan. 2007. ‘Authenticity as Authentication’. In Critical Essays in Popular Musicology,
    ed. Allan F. Moore, 131–45. Aldershot: Ashgate.
    Moore, Hilary. 2007. ‘Ken Colyer and the Trad Jazz Movement: Class, Authenticity and the
    Nostalgic Imagination’. In Hilary Moore, Inside British Jazz: Crossing Borders of Race,
    Nation and Class, 37–65. Aldershot: Ashgate.
    Ogren, Kathy. 1989. The Jazz Revolution: Twenties America and the Meaning of Jazz. New York:
    Oxford University Press.
    Panassié, Hugues. 1942. The Real Jazz. New York: Smith and Durrell.
    Pawson, Dan. 2001a. ‘Dan Pawson’. In Mike Burns, The Great Olympia Band, 83–89. New
    Orleans: Jazzology Press.
    —2001b. ‘Repertoire’. Letter to the Editor. New Orleans Music 9.4: 13–14.
    Pickering, Michael, and Emily Keightley. 2006. ‘The Modalities of Nostalgia’. Current Sociology
    54.6: 919–41. http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0011392106068458
    Pointon, Mike, and Ray Smith. 2010. Goin’ Home: The Uncompromising Life and Music of Ken
    Colyer. London: The Ken Colyer Trust.
    Raeburn, Bruce Boyd. 2009. New Orleans Style and the Writing of American Jazz History. Ann
    Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
    Ramsey, Jr., Frederic, and Charles Edward Smith. 1939. Jazzmen. New York: Harcourt.
    Ramsey, Jr., Guthrie P. 1996. ‘Cosmopolitan or Provincial?: Ideology in Early Black Music
    Historiography, 1867–1940’. Black Music Research Journal 16.1: 11–42. http://dx.doi.
    org/10.2307/779375
    Rossiter, P. 1955. ‘The Revivalists’. In Jazzbook 1955, ed. Albert J. McCarthy, 49–64. London:
    Cassell.
    Russell, William. 1940. ‘Delta—New Orleans’. HRS Society Rag, October, 28–30.
    Shipton, Alyn. 2007. A New History of Jazz, revised and updated ed. New York: Continuum.
    Shuker, Roy. 2005. Popular Music: The Key Concepts, 2nd ed. London: Routledge.
    Smith, Charles Edward. 1930. ‘Jazz: Some Little Known Aspects’. Symposium: A Critical
    Review 1 (October): 502–17.
    —1935. ‘Heat Wave’. Stage, September: 45–46.
    Smith, Charles Edward, with Frederic Ramsey, Jr., Charles Payne Rogers and William Russell.
    1943. The Jazz Record Book. New York: Smith and Durrell.
    Smits, Guus, and Gerard Bielderman. 2010. A Discography of Kid Thomas Valentine. Zwolle,
    The Netherlands: Gerard Bielderman.
    Stewart, Jack. 2005–2006. ‘The Original Dixieland Jazz Band’s Place in the Development of
    Jazz’. Jazz Archivist 19: 16–25.
    Suhor, Charles. 2001. ‘New Orleans Jazz with a Foreign Accent’. In Charles Suhor, Jazz in New
    Orleans: The Postwar Years through 1972, 187–91. London: Scarecrow Press; Rutgers:
    State University of New Jersey.
    Thornton, S. 1995. Club Cultures: Music, Media and Subcultural Capital. London: Polity Press.
    Turner, Frederick. 1994. Remembering Song: Encounters with New Orleans Jazzmen, expanded
    ed. New York: Da Capo Press.
    Unruh, David. 1979. ‘Characteristics and Types of Participation in Social Worlds’. Symbolic
    Interaction 2.2: 115–29. http://dx.doi.org/10.1525/si.1979.2.2.115
    Williams, Martin. 1969. Jazz Masters of New Orleans. New York: Macmillan.
    Wright, Laurie. 1987. King Oliver. Chigwell, Essex: Storyville Publications.
    Yanow, Scott. 2001. Trumpet Kings: The Players who Shaped the Sound of Jazz Trumpet. San
    Francisco: Backbeat Books.
    Zimmerman, Don H., and Melvin Pollner. 1971. ‘The Everyday World as a Phenomenon’. In
    Understanding Everyday Life, ed. Jack Douglas, 80–103. London: Routledge.

    Keywords

    • authenticating
    • authenticity
    • Dan Pawson
    • grounded theory
    • Ken Colyer
    • New
    • Orleans jazz revivalism
    • social worlds

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'Authenticity as authenticating—the case of New Orleans jazz revivalism: An approach from grounded theory and social world analysis'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this