Performance and operational effectiveness of evacuated flat plate solar collectors compared with conventional thermal, PVT and PV panels

Roger Moss, Paul Henshall, Farid Arya, Stan Shire, Trevor Hyde, Philip Eames

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

42 Citations (Scopus)
223 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The concept of an evacuated flat plate (EFP) collector was proposed over 40 years ago but, despite its professed advantages, very few manufacturers have developed commercial versions. This situation suggests both technical difficulties in manufacturing a competitively-priced sealed for life panel and a lack of awareness of the benefits of such panels.

This paper demonstrates an evacuated flat plate simulation that closely models experimental efficiency measurements. Having established the validity of the model, it compares published data for a commercial EFP collector with predictions for an optimal design to investigate whether any further efficiency improvement might be possible. The optimised design is then evaluated against alternative solar energy devices by modelling a number of possible applications. These comparisons should inform choices about solar options for delivering heat: EFP collectors are well-suited to some of these applications.

Evacuated flat plate collectors are a possible alternative to concentrating collectors for Organic Rankine Cycle power generation. The annual output for all the modelled collectors was found to be a quadratic function of delivery temperature: this enabled a novel optimisation of ORC source temperature. Predictions for concentrating and non-concentrating ORC plant are compared with a PV/thermal alternative. The ORC output is significantly less than a PV panel would achieve; applications needing both heat and power are better served by PVT panels. This is an original and novel result.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)588-601
Number of pages14
JournalApplied Energy
Volume216
Early online date23 Feb 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Apr 2018

Bibliographical note

Reference text: Abbate, P., Presentation on the TVP evacuated panel at InterSolar 2012, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_4FD4Zxwew accessed 12/7/2017
Abdelhamid, M., Widyolar, B.K., Jiang, L., Winton, R., Yablonovitch, E., Scranton, G., Cygan, D., Abbasi, H. and Kozlov, A. Novel double-stage high-concentrated solar hybrid photovoltaic/thermal (PV/T) collector with nonimaging optics and GaAs solar cells reflector. Applied Energy 182 (2016) 68-79
Agrawal, S. and Tiwari, G.N., Energy and exergy analysis of hybrid micro-channel photovoltaic thermal module. Solar Energy 85 (2011) 356-370.
Alam, M., Singh, H., Suresh, S. and Redpath, D.A.G., Energy and economic analysis of Vacuum Insulation Panels (VIPs) used in non-domestic buildings, Applied Energy 188 (2017) 1-8
Alobaid, M., Hughes, B., Calautit, J.K., O’Connor, D. and Heyes, A., A review of solar driven absorption cooling with photovoltaic thermal systems, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Volume 76, September 2017, Pages 728–742
Amrizal, N., Chemisana, D. and Rosell, J.I., Hybrid photovoltaic–thermal solar collectors dynamic modelling. Applied Energy 101 (2013) 797-807.
Ancona, M.A., Bianchi, M., Diolaiti, E., Giannuzzi, A., Marano, B., Melino, F. and Peretto, A, A novel solar concentrator system for combined heat and power application in residential sector. Applied Energy 185 (2017) 1199-1209
Beikircher, T., Möckl, M., Osgyan, P. and Streib, G, Advanced solar flat plate collectors with full area absorber, front side film and rear side vacuum superinsulation, Solar Energy Materials & Solar Cells, 141 (2015) 308-406
Benvenuti, C. and Ruzinov, V., The SRB evacuated flat solar panel, Proceedings of ECOS 2010, pp2-429 to 434.
Benvenuti, C., (2013a) The SRB solar thermal panel, Europhysics News March 2013, DOI: 10.1051/epn/2013301, p16-18
Benvenuti, C, (2013b) Particle accelerators and solar panels, Fisica E. Vol29, No1-2, 2013 pp31-38 (NEG Non-evaporable getters etc)
Benz, N. and T. Beikircher, T., High efficiency evacuated flat-plate solar collector for process steam production. Solar Energy 65 (1999) No. 2 pp 111-118
Bianchini, A., Guzzini, A., Pellegrini, M. and Saccani, C., Photovoltaic/thermal (PV/T) solar system: Experimental measurements, performance analysis and economic assessment. Renewable Energy 111 (2017) 543-555
Bouvier, J-L, Michaux, G., Salagnac, P., Kientz, T. and Rochier, D., Experimental study of a micro combined heat and power system with a solar parabolic trough collector coupled to a steam Rankine cycle expander, Solar Energy 134 (2016) 180-192
Brunold, S., Frey, R and Frei, U., A comparison of three different collectors for process heat applications. SPF publication. http://spf.ch/fileadmin/daten/publ/procheat.pdf
Busby, J., UK shallow ground temperatures for ground coupled heat exchangers. Quarterly Journal of Engineering Geology and Hydrogeology, 48, 248-260, 28 October 2015, https://0-doi-org.pugwash.lib.warwick.ac.uk/10.1144/qjegh2015-077

Buttinger, F., Beikircher, T., Proll, M. and Scholkopf, W., Development of a new flat stationary evacuated CPC-collector for process heat applications Solar Energy 84 (2010) 1166-1174
Caër, V.H-L., De Chambriera, E., Mertina, S., Jolya, M., Schaerb, M and Scartezzinia, J-L, Optical and morphological characterisation of low refractive index materials for coatings on solar collector glazing. Renewable Energy Vol.53, May 2013, pp27-34.
Chapuis, S. and Bernier, M. Seasonal storage of solar energy in borehole heat exchangers. Proc. 11th International Building Performance Simulation Association (IBPSA) meeting 2009, Glasgow, 599-606.
Cohen, S. and Grossman, G., Development of a solar collector with a stationary spherical reflector/tracking absorber for industrial process heat, Solar Energy 128 (2016) 31-40
Colangelo, G., Favale, E., Miglietta, P., de Risi, A., Milanese, M. and Laforgia, D., Experimental test of an innovative high concentration nanofluid solar collector, Applied Energy 154 (2015) pp 874-881
Colangelo, G., Favale, E., Miglietta, P. and de Risi, A. Innovation in flat solar thermal collectors: A review of the last ten years’ experimental results. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 57 (2016) pp 1141–1159
Crisostomo, F., Hjerrild, N., Mesgari, S., Li, Q. and Taylor, R.A., A hybrid PV/T collector using spectrally selective absorbing nanofluids. Applied Energy 193 (2017) 1-14
DIN CERTCO test certificates http://www.dincertco.tuv.com accessed August 2017
DTI, Energy consumption in the United Kingdom (2001) http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http:/www.berr.gov.uk/files/file11250.pdf
Duffie, J.A. and Beckman, W.A., Solar Engineering of Thermal Processes, 4th edition, Wiley, 2013.
Ehrmann, N. and Reineke-Koch, R., Selectively coated high efficiency glazing for solar-thermal flat-plate collectors. Thin Solid Films 520 (2012) 4214-4218.
Evinox data sheet (downloaded 28/11/2017): http://www.evinoxenergy.co.uk/Sites/Evinox/library/files/PHRIE%20ASHP%20Data%20Sheet.pdf
Freeman, J., Hellgardt, K. and Markides, C.N., An Assessment of Solar–Thermal Collector Designs for Small-Scale Combined Heating and Power Applications in the United Kingdom, Heat Transfer Engineering Vol. 36 , Issue 14-15,2015, doi: 10.1080/01457632.2015.995037
Gao, X-H., Theiss. W., Shen, Y-Q., Ma, P-J. and Liu, G., Optical simulation, corrosion behavior and long term thermal stability of TiC-based spectrally selective solar absorbers. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 167 (2017) 150-156
Gao, Y., Zhang, Q., Fan, R., Lin, X. And Yu, Y., Effects of thermal mass and flow rate on forced-circulation solar hot-water system: Comparison of water-in-glass and U-pipe evacuated-tube solar collectors, Solar Energy 98 (2013) 290-301
Henshall, P., Moss, R., Arya, F., Eames, P.C, Shires, S. and Hyde, T., An evacuated enclosure design for solar thermal energy applications. Grand Renewable Energy 2014 (GRE2014) International Conference and Exhibition, Tokyo, Japan, 27 July - 1 August 2014, https://dspace.lboro.ac.uk/2134/16098

Herrando, M. and Markides, C., Hybrid PV and solar-thermal systems for domestic heat and power provision in the UK: Techno-economic considerations. Applied Energy 161 (2016) 512-532
Joly, M., Antonetti, Y., Python, M., Gonzalez, M., Gascou, T., Scartezzini, J-L, Schuler, A., Novel black selective coating for tubular solar absorbers based on a sol–gel method, Solar Energy 94 (2013) 233-239
Kalogirou, S.A., Solar Energy Engineering, Second Edition, Academic Press 2014.
Landelle, A., Tauveron, N., Haberschill, P., Revellin, R. and Colasson, S., Organic Rankine cycle design and performance comparison based on experimental database. Applied Energy 204 (2017) 1172-1187.
Lee, D-S., Hung, T-C., Lin, J-R. and Zhao, J., Experimental investigations on solar chimney for optimal heat collection to be utilized in organic Rankine cycle. Applied Energy 154 (2015) 651-662.
Leone, G. and Beccali, M., Use of finite element models for estimating thermal performance of façade-integrated solar thermal collectors, Applied Energy 171 (2016) 392-404
Li, Q., Zheng, C., Shirazi, A., Mousa, O.B., Moscia, F. and Scott, J.A., Design and analysis of a medium-temperature, concentrated solar thermal collector for air-conditioning applications, Applied Energy 190 (2017) 1159-1173
Lira-Cantu´, M., Sabio, A.M., Brustenga, A., Go´mez-Romero, P., Electrochemical deposition of black nickel solar absorber coatings on stainless steel AISI316L for thermal solar cells, Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 87 (2005) 685-694
Lizama-Tzec, F.I., Macías J.D., Estrella-Gutiérrez , M.A., Cahue-López , A.C., Arés, O., de Coss, R., Alvarado-Gil, J.J. and Oskam, G., Electrodeposition and characterization of nanostructured black nickel selective absorber coatings for solar–thermal energy conversion. J. Materials Science: Mater Electron (2015) 26:5553–5561, DOI 10.1007/s10854-014-2195-5
Matuska, T., Sourek, B., Jirka, V. and Pokorny, N., Glazed PVT Collector with Polysiloxane Encapsulation of PV Cells: Performance and Economic Analysis, International Journal of Photoenergy, 2015, http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/718316
McDonald, G.E., Spectral reflectance properties of black chrome for use as a solar selective coating, Solar Energy vol 17, 1975, pp119-122
Modjinou, M., Ji, J., Li, J., Yuan, W. and Zhou, F., A numerical and experimental study of micro-channel heat pipe solar photovoltaics thermal system. Applied Energy 206 (2017) 708-722
Moss, R.W., Shire, G.S.F., Henshall, P., Eames, P.C., Arya, F. and Hyde, T. (2017a) Optimal passage size for solar collector micro-channel and tube-on-plate absorbers. Solar Energy, September 2017 vol.153 pp718-731, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.solener.2017.05.030
Moss, R.W., Shire, G.S.F., Henshall, P., Eames, P.C., Arya, F. and Hyde, T. (2017b) Design and fabrication of a hydro-formed absorber for an evacuated solar collector. Submitted to Applied Thermal Engineering
Moss, R.W., Shire, G.S.F., Eames, P.C., Henshall, P., Hyde, T. and Arya, F., (2017c) Design and commissioning of a virtual image solar simulator for testing thermal collectors. Solar Energy vol.159, Jan 2018 pp234-242, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.solener.2017.10.044
Moss, R.W., Henshall, P., Arya, F., Shire, G.S.F., Eames, P.C and Hyde, T. (2017d), Simulator testing of evacuated flat plate solar collectors for industrial heat and building integration. Being submitted to Solar Energy.
Mwesigye, A. and Meyer. J.P., Optimal thermal and thermodynamic performance of a solar parabolic trough receiver with different nanofluids and at different concentration ratios, Applied Energy 193 (2017) 393-413
NEP PolyTrough 1800 datasheet accessed August 2017 http://www.nep-solar.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/NEP-Solar-Polytrough1800_Datasheet.pdf
Nkwetta, D.N. and Smythe, M., The potential applications and advantages of powering solar air-conditioning systems using concentrator augmented solar collectors. Applied Energy 89 (2012) 380-386.
O’Hegarty, R, Kinnane, O and McCormack, S.J., Concrete solar collectors for façade integration: An experimental and numerical investigation. Applied Energy 206 (2017) 1040-1061
Palz, W. and Greif, J., Commission of the European Communities. European Solar Radiation Atlas, Third Ed., Springer (1996) p326.
Purohit, I and Purohit, P, Technical and economic potential of concentrating solar thermal power generation in India, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 78 (2017) 648–66
Quoilin, S., Orosz, M., Hemond, H. and Lemort, V, Performance and design optimization of a low-cost solar organic Rankine cycle for remote power generation. Solar Energy 85 (2011) 955-966
Qu, W. Wang, R., Hong, H., Sun, J. and Jin, H., Test of a solar parabolic trough collector with rotatable axis tracking. Applied Energy xxx (2017) xxx-xxx (in press)
Rad, F.M. and Fung, A.S., Solar community heating and cooling system with borehole thermal energy storage –Review of systems. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 60 (2016) 1550-1561
Riggs, B.C., Biedenharn, R., Dougher, C., Ji, Y.V., Xu, Q., Romanin, V., Codd, D.S., Zahler, J.M. and Escarra, M.D., Techno-economic analysis of hybrid PV/T systems for process heat using electricity to subsidize the cost of heat. Applied Energy 208 (2017) pp1370-1378
RISE, ScenoCalc home page http://www.sp.se/en/index/services/solar/ScenoCalc/Sidor/default.aspx accessed December 2017.
Rodríguez-Hidalgo , M.C., Rodríguez-Aumente, P.A., Lecuona, A, Gutiérrez-Urueta, G.L. and Ventas, R. Flat plate thermal solar collector efficiency: Transient behavior under working conditions. Part I: Model description and experimental validation. Applied Thermal Engineering 31 (2011) 2394-2404
Selvakumar, N. and Barshilia, H.C., Review of physical vapor deposited (PVD) spectrally selective coatings for mid- and high-temperature solar thermal applications. Solar Energy Materials & Solar Cells 98 (2012) 1–23
SPF catalogue of solar collector test results http://www.spf.ch/index.php?id=111&L=6 accessed August 2017.
TVP Solar, MT-30 datasheet, http://www.tvpsolar.com/files/pagine/1464011780_MT-Power%20Datasheet%20(v4.2x)(ver5).pdf accessed 12/7/2017
Su, W., Zhao, L., Deng, S., Xu, W. and Yu, Z. A limiting efficiency of subcritical Organic Rankine cycle under the constraint of working fluids. Energy 143 (2018) pp458-466.
Suman, S., Khan, M.K., Pathak, M., Performance enhancement of solar collectors – a review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 49 (2015) 192-210.
Thorpe, University of Warwick Weather Station (online) https://www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/sciencecity/programmes/internal/themes/energyefficiency/thermal/bookings/weather_station/ accessed October 2017.
Wang, J., Yin, Z., Qi, J., Ma, G and Liu, X., Medium-temperature solar collectors with all-glass solar evacuated tubes, Energy Procedia 70 (2015) 126 – 129
Zambolin, E. and Col, D.D., Experimental analysis of thermal performance of flat plate and evacuated tube solar collectors in stationary standard and daily conditions, Solar Energy 84 (2010) 1382-1396
Zima, W and Dziewa, P., Modelling of liquid flat-plate solar collector operation in transient states. Proc. IMechE Vol. 225 Part A (2010) J. Power and Energy pp 53-62.
Zou, B., Dong, J., Yao, Y. and Jiang, Y., An experimental investigation on a small-sized parabolic trough solar collector for water heating in cold areas, Applied Energy 163 (2016) 396-407

Keywords

  • Evacuated
  • flat plate
  • solar
  • collector
  • Organic Rankine cycle
  • weather

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Performance and operational effectiveness of evacuated flat plate solar collectors compared with conventional thermal, PVT and PV panels'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this